The 3 best ice cream shops in Grand Rapids, as chosen by readers

Ice cream at Frosty Boy in Grand Rapids MI

Photo courtesy of Frosty Boy Grand Rapids

By The 'Gander Staff

May 6, 2024

Summer is coming, so we asked our readers to give us their picks for the best ice cream places in Grand Rapids. After a month of voting, the results are in, with three ice cream shops rising to the top. Whether you’re a local resident or just visiting, these spots are a must-visit for any ice cream lover in the area. So, grab a cone and let’s dive into the delicious world of ice cream in Grand Rapids!

3. Love’s Ice Cream & Chocolate

For those with a penchant for the sweeter things in life, Love’s Ice Cream & Chocolate is like stepping into a dream where every bite is a slice of heaven. This enchanting shop is a haven for anyone with a deep-seated love for ice cream and chocolate. Imagine the creamiest, most flavorful scoop of ice cream, paired with the rich, velvety smoothness of artisanal chocolate. Yes, it’s as delectable as it sounds!

At Love’s, the passion for creating exceptional desserts shines through in every scoop and bite. This is a place where the art of dessert-making is taken to new heights. The ice cream selection ranges from the luxuriously rich to the refreshingly fruity, ensuring that there’s a flavor to suit every mood and craving. Have you ever had the joy of tasting a scoop of raspberry cheesecake ice cream? Or perhaps the exotic allure of cardamom orange blossom gelato is more your style? Love’s makes these dreams a reality, blending high-quality ingredients to craft unforgettable flavors.

But let’s not forget the chocolate – the co-star of this delightful show. Love’s prides itself on its exquisite range of chocolate offerings, each piece a masterpiece of confectionery skill. The chocolates, handcrafted with the same level of care and attention as their ice creams, are perfect for those moments when only the most indulgent treat will do. Whether you’re savoring a piece on its own or enjoying it as a decadent topping on your ice cream, the experience is nothing short of magical.

Love’s Ice Cream & Chocolate is about creating moments of joy and pleasure through the medium of desserts. The shop’s commitment to using quality ingredients means that every scoop and every bite not only tastes incredible but also feels like a guilt-free indulgence. For those with dietary restrictions, fear not! Love’s offers a range of options to ensure that everyone can partake in the joy, including vegan and gluten-free choices.

The atmosphere at Love’s Ice Cream & Chocolate adds another layer to the delightful experience. The warm, inviting space is the perfect backdrop for savoring these treats, whether you’re sharing a moment with loved ones or indulging in a solo treat. The friendly staff are always on hand to offer recommendations, share the stories behind their flavors, and add that personal touch that makes each visit feel special.

In a city celebrated for its culinary scene, Love’s stands out as a beacon for those who believe dessert is an experience to be savored. It’s a place where every visit is an adventure, every flavor a discovery, and every bite a reason to smile. So, the next time you’re in Grand Rapids and your sweet tooth calls, let Love’s be your guide to a world of exquisite flavors and indulgent treats. After all, life is short, and dessert, especially when it’s this good, should never be an afterthought.

2. Furniture City Creamery

Furniture City Creamery in Grand Rapids

Photo courtesy of Furniture City Creamery

Step into Furniture City Creamery and immediately find yourself enveloped in a world where creativity and quality ingredients take the lead. This Grand Rapids gem is a sanctuary for those who appreciate the art of ice cream making. At Furniture City Creamery, every scoop tells a story of local pride and artisanal craft.

The shop’s cozy atmosphere, with its quaint decor and welcoming vibe, sets the stage for an ice cream experience unlike any other. Here, the focus is on small-batch, handcrafted ice cream that shines a spotlight on locally sourced ingredients. It’s this dedication to quality that makes each visit to Furniture City Creamery feel both special and personal.

One thing we love about Furniture City? The playful menu, full of entries like D’OUGH! and You’ve Got a Lot of (Malt) Balls. And the taste matches the creativity. The creamery thrives on pushing the boundaries of taste, blending the familiar with the unexpected to create something memorable. Each flavor, from the rich and decadent to the light and refreshing, is crafted to surprise and delight.

And for those who revel in the excitement of new culinary experiences, Furniture City Creamery’s rotating seasonal flavors are like a treasure trove waiting to be discovered. These limited-time offerings reflect the essence of the seasons, allowing patrons to embark on a flavorful journey through the year. Whether it’s the refreshing zest of a summer citrus blend or the cozy warmth of a fall spice mix, there’s always something new to savor.

But it’s about more than the ice cream. Furniture City Creamery’s commitment to an exceptional customer experience is evident in every detail, from the friendly staff who greet you like an old friend to the passion and care poured into each batch of ice cream. It’s a place where you’re encouraged to linger, explore, and indulge your senses.

For those who cherish the art of ice cream and seek out the unique and handcrafted, Furniture City Creamery is a beacon of culinary creativity. It’s a spot where you can connect with the community, appreciate the craft of ice cream making, and, of course, treat yourself to some of the most delectable flavors in Grand Rapids. In this cozy corner of the city, every scoop is an adventure, inviting you to dive into the rich tapestry of artisanal creations that await.

1. Frosty Boy

Walking up to Frosty Boy is like stepping into a sweet, frosty wonderland where every flavor of ice cream you could dream of is waiting to be discovered. This local gem has been whipping up delicious cones, cups, and sundaes that have locals and visitors alike coming back time and time again. It’s a beacon for those seeking a taste of nostalgia mixed with innovative, mouth-watering flavors.

At Frosty Boy, the menu is a vibrant tapestry of choices, catering to every palate. From the timeless appeal of creamy vanilla and rich chocolate to the playful burst of cotton candy and the unique tang of bubblegum, it’s a place where the classic and the unconventional live in perfect harmony. Every scoop is a testament to Frosty Boy’s dedication to bringing joy and satisfaction to their customers’ taste buds.

Imagine a twirl of the smoothest, creamiest ice cream, so light and airy, yet bursting with flavor, perched atop a crispy cone or in a fluffy cloud-like cup. Now, add your choice of colorful sprinkles, a drizzle of silky hot fudge, or a dollop of peanut butter sauce, and you’ve got yourself a treat. It’s these magical concoctions that make first-time visitors become lifelong fans.

The charm of Frosty Boy goes beyond its delightful offerings to the atmosphere. There’s something incredibly welcoming about the place, with its friendly staff ready to greet you with a smile and the infectious excitement of deciding which flavor to try next. It’s a spot where memories are made, whether it’s a family outing on a sunny Saturday afternoon or a sweet end to a perfect date night.

In Grand Rapids, where every season brings its own magic, Frosty Boy is a constant. It’s where summer’s warmth is celebrated with a cone in hand, and even when the air turns crisp, the love for ice cream doesn’t wane—thanks to Frosty Boy’s irresistible flavors and the joy of indulging in a frozen treat, no matter the weather.

So, if you find yourself wandering the streets of Grand Rapids with a craving for something sweet, let Frosty Boy be your destination. Here, ice cream is a frosty delight that promises to bring a smile to your face and a moment of pure, unadulterated happiness. Dive into the world of Frosty Boy, and let each scoop be an adventure.

FOOD HISTORY: Michigan’s favorite ice cream was born in a brewery





Local News

Related Stories
Share This