The 9 best pizzas in Michigan, according to our research

Photo courtesy of Niki's Pizza

By The 'Gander Staff

April 26, 2024

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Michigan, the options are endless. From the bustling city of Detroit to the quaint town of Cadillac, there’s no shortage of delicious pizza joints to satisfy your cravings. After conducting extensive research, we’ve compiled a list of the top contenders for the title of the best pies in Michigan.

Best Pizza in Detroit: Niki’s Pizza

Nestled in downtown Detroit, a city renowned for its rich history and cultural tapestry, Niki’s Pizza stands as a testament to the enduring allure of authentic Detroit-style pie. This legendary spot has carved out its niche in the competitive Detroit pizza scene with a unique blend of traditional craftsmanship and a zest for innovation that keeps locals and visitors flocking to its doors.

At Niki’s, it’s all about the crust. Their distinctive square pies feature a buttery, thick crust that’s simultaneously crispy and airy, providing a perfect base for the rich, flavorful toppings that are generously heaped on top.

But it doesn’t stop there. Niki’s commitment to quality is evident in every slice, from their robust sauce that sings with hints of garlic and oregano to the premium toppings that are sourced with care.

Whether you opt for a classic choice like their Famous Pepperoni or venture into the realm of their specialties like the Greek, each choice is a revelation, bursting with flavors that are both comforting and exciting. The ambiance at Niki’s adds to the charm. Its walls, adorned with memorabilia, echo the spirit of Detroit, creating a casual, friendly environment where every meal feels like a gathering of friends. In a city that’s no stranger to pizza, Niki’s distinguishes itself by honoring its roots while embracing the future. It’s a place where each bite is a blend of history, culture, and the undeniable joy of eating a great slice. That’s what makes Niki’s a slice of the city’s heart.

Best Pizza in Cadillac: Pizza Plus

Tucked away in the serene surroundings of Cadillac, a small town that might not be the first place you think of when dreaming about top-notch pizza, is where you’ll find the delightful surprise of Pizza Plus. This cozy spot has carved out a reputation for serving what many believe to be the best pie in the area, and it’s easy to see why once you’ve had a taste.

At Pizza Plus, the magic starts with the crust. The team here knows that the foundation of any great pizza is its base, and they’ve perfected a hand-tossed crust that strikes the ideal balance between chewy and crispy. It’s this attention to detail and dedication to the craft that sets Pizza Plus apart from the crowd.

Each pie is adorned with a lavish spread of fresh, high-quality toppings that come together in a spectacular display of artistry. Whether you lean towards the classics or prefer to explore more adventurous toppings, Pizza Plus offers a diverse menu that caters to every palate. Their commitment to fresh ingredients shines through in every bite, creating a flavor profile that’s as rich and varied as the landscape of Michigan itself.

One of the hallmarks of Pizza Plus is their innovative approach. This is a place where creativity meets tradition in the kitchen. With a variety of specialties that feature unexpected yet harmonious combinations, there’s always something new and exciting to try. It’s this spirit of innovation, coupled with a deep respect for traditional techniques, that has endeared Pizza Plus to the hearts of Cadillac’s residents and visitors alike.

The ambiance of Pizza Plus adds another layer to its charm. Walking into the restaurant, you’re immediately enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a welcoming embrace. The friendly staff greet you with smiles, ready to guide you through your culinary journey.

Whether you’re a local in search of your next pizza fix or a traveler passing through the beautiful town of Cadillac, a stop at Pizza Plus is a must. It’s the kind of place that leaves a lasting impression through the passion and warmth that permeate every aspect of your visit. So, if you find yourself yearning for a slice that transcends the ordinary, head over to Pizza Plus. Here, you’ll discover a place where every slice tells a story of culinary excellence and heartfelt hospitality.

Best Pizza in Kalamazoo: Pizza Katerina

Kalamazoo, a city bursting with vibrant energy and a thriving culinary scene, is home to Pizza Katerina, a gem that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike.

Here, pizza is an art form. The passion behind each pie is evident, from the meticulously sourced ingredients to the careful craftsmanship that goes into every slice. The crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, serving as a delicious foundation for the explosion of flavors on top.

What sets Pizza Katerina apart is their daring flavor combinations. They’re not afraid to experiment, blending classic toppings with unexpected ingredients to create pies that are both comforting and thrilling. Their menu is a testament to creativity, inviting pizza lovers to explore new tastes and textures.

The atmosphere at Pizza Katerina is as inviting as their menu. It’s a place where laughter fills the air, where each table shares stories over slices, creating a sense of community and joy.

For those on a quest to discover the best pizza in Kalamazoo, Pizza Katerina is an adventure for the palate, promising an experience that’s as memorable as it is delicious.

Best Pizza in Flint: Bongiorno’s Pizza

Flint, a city known for its resilience, is home to a treasure trove for pizza enthusiasts. Bongiorno’s Pizza, a gem in the city’s culinary crown, has been drawing in locals and visitors alike with its irresistible slices that speak to the soul of Italian cooking. This family-owned haven of deliciousness is where tradition meets innovation on a pizza plate.

Walking into Bongiorno’s Pizza, you’re immediately welcomed by an atmosphere that’s both cozy and buzzing with excitement. The aroma of freshly baked pies wafting through the air is enough to make your stomach rumble in anticipation. Here, every pizza is crafted with a level of care and attention to detail that’s becoming rare. It’s clear from the get-go that this is a place where the art of pizza-making is alive and well.

The menu at Bongiorno’s Pizza is a delightful blend of classic favorites and imaginative creations. Their signature thin crust is something of a local legend, providing the perfect crispy base for a plethora of top-quality toppings. Each crust is a canvas, and the folks at Bongiorno’s are the artists, balancing flavors and textures to produce pies that are nothing short of masterpieces.

What sets Bongiorno’s apart from the crowd is their unwavering commitment to using only the freshest ingredients. Whether it’s the tangy tomato sauce, the creamy mozzarella, or the vibrant array of vegetables and meats that adorn their pizzas, you can taste the difference that quality makes. It’s this dedication to excellence that has cemented Bongiorno’s Pizza as a must-visit destination for anyone in search of the best pizza in Flint.

The warm and welcoming staff at Bongiorno’s make you feel like part of the family from the moment you step inside. It’s the kind of place where new friendships are formed over a shared love for pizza, and where every visit feels like a celebration. In a world where dining out can sometimes feel impersonal, the sense of community at Bongiorno’s is a breath of fresh air.

As you bite into a slice of Bongiorno’s pizza, it’s easy to understand why this place has captured the hearts of so many. The crisp crust, the melding flavors of the toppings, and the gooey cheese create a symphony of tastes that’s unforgettable. It’s an experience that transports you straight to the streets of Italy, where pizza is a way of life.

So, if you find yourself in Flint with a craving for something special, make your way to Bongiorno’s Pizza. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or just looking for a delicious meal, you’ll find something to love at this beloved pizzeria. In a city full of stories, Bongiorno’s Pizza adds its own chapter, one of passion, tradition, and unforgettable pizza.