While we got loads of responses, the pasty was by far the most popular answer, taking up the vast majority of responses. So, I suppose that settles it?
By the way, If you’re curious to learn more about how this local delicacy came to be, you’re in luck, I wrote about its history not too long ago.
That being said, there are other dishes worth considering for the title. Here’s highlights of what you had to say:
“I think the state dish would be cherry pie, what is more Michigan than that?” — Anita, Port Huron
“This is a hard one. There are so many dishes that may not have originated but that we adopted in Michigan. I’m from New Boston, a small town just south of the Metro airport. I live out of state now but I’m retiring soon and moving back! I’m homesick. If I had to pick one meal it would be a multiple choice type switch out meal…Either Detroit deep dish pizza with a few Better made chips and a Faygo Rock n Rye top it off with a couple cider donuts from Apple Charley’s in New Boston. The swap out meal would be wet burrito from Detroit with a Vernors and some Mackinac fudge for desert. I miss the great delis in Michigan and Greek town food as well as white castles that I learned to love there along with everything apple from my home spot and the loose meat subs from various shops. There is also great middle eastern food in Michigan.” — Karen, New Boston
“It is said that Michigan is the home of the olive burger. It is the only addictive substance not yet banned by the Food & Drug Administration, yet still legal to eat.” — Le Roy, Grand Ledge
“The state dish has to be the Coney Dog for the lower peninsula and the Pasty for the UP.” — Janette, Jackson
“For the UP I would say pasties. For the lower, Detroit style pizza and any type of casserole!” — Anna, Brighton
“Pasties! Or Cherries!” — Sue, Williamston
“Whitefish.” — Dan, Lakeside
“Pasties and coney dogs, couldn’t choose between the two!” — Susan, Grand Ledge