Last week, President Donald Trump’s education secretary flew to Michigan with one mission: pressuring our governor to sign on to a school voucher scheme that Michiganders already voted down once. She held a press conference, she wrote an op-ed, and if she gets her way, it could fundamentally change what public education looks like in this state.
Here’s the deal: The program is called the Education Freedom Tax Credit. It was one of many things tucked inside Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill, and it works like this: Wealthy donors give money to private, nonprofit scholarship organizations. In turn, they get every dollar back as a federal tax credit. And those organizations then hand out the money to families to cover things like private school tuition, homeschooling, and other education costs.
Governors in at least 29 states have already signed up for the program. Almost all of them Republican. And if you’ve been in Michigan long enough, this should feel familiar, because it’s basically the same scheme that Betsy DeVos has tried to force on this state for years. The same one Whitmer vetoed in 2021, the same one that stalled out before it could make the ballot in 2023. And the same one that Michigan voters have been repeatedly rejecting at the ballot box for decades. So why is it back?
Because now this same type of scheme is baked into federal law, and all it takes is a governor’s signature to unlock it here. Last week, US Education Secretary Linda McMahon flew to Hamtramck, specifically to make that ask. She stood in front of cameras at a charter school and told Whitmer to opt in. Republican lawmakers in Lansing are also pushing Whitmer to sign on.
But here’s the thing: Data from similar programs already running in other states shows the vast majority of these scholarships are going out to students who were already in private school before the program existed.
So what? Well, Whitmer hasn’t said yes. She’s calling it a high-level talking point, and there’s not enough detail yet to make a call. That’s not exactly a full-throated rejection. It’s not a signature, either. Still, the Trump administration is counting on this pressure campaign eventually working. And if Michigan ends up with a Republican governor after 2026, it almost certainly will.
Get the full story in this edition of “so what, Michigan?“