Michigan Senate passes bill to ban ‘gay panic’ defense

A bill that would bar the “gay panic” and “trans panic” defenses from being used in court was passed Thursday by the state Senate.

Michigan Advance

June 25, 2024

BY JON KING, MICHIGAN ADVANCE

MICHIGAN—A bill that would bar the “gay panic” and “trans panic” defenses from being used in court was passed Thursday by the state Senate.

House Bill 4718 would prohibit using a legal defense that would either partially or completely excuse crimes such as murder and assault on the grounds that the victim’s sexual orientation or gender identity were to blame.

It passed 24-14, with four Republicans—Sens. Mark Huizenga (R-Walker), Dan Lauwers (R-Brockway), Jonathan Lindsey (R-Sturgis), and Ed McBroom (Vulcan)—joining all Democrats voting in favor.

That was in contrast to when state Rep. Laurie Pohutsky (D-Livonia) put forward the bill last year and it passed the House on a 56-53 party line vote, with every Republican who was present voting against it.

Testifying during committee hearings in March about the bill, Pohutsky said the defense is often used as a way to play on the prejudices of judges and juries in an effort to mitigate criminal penalties.

“At its core, the defense asserts that crimes against the LGBTQ community carry less weight because we are inherently less human and therefore less valuable,” she said.

In 2013, the American Bar Association advised federal and local governments to bar legal defenses that, “seek to partially or completely excuse crimes such as murder and assault on the grounds that the victim’s sexual orientation or gender identity is to blame for the defendant’s violent reaction.”

The legislation is supported by several organizations, including the Human Rights Campaign, the LGBTQ+ Section of the State Bar of Michigan, the Michigan League for Public Policy, and the Equality Michigan Action Network, which said the Senate passage takes “one step closer to ensuring that a victim’s LGBTQ+ status cannot be used to undermine justice.”

The legislation now moves back to the state House for final approval before sending it to Gov. Whitmer for her expected signature.

This coverage was republished from Michigan Advance pursuant to a Creative Commons license.

Keep The 'Gander free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting The 'Gander?

Every day, our team works to provide Michiganders with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local news—not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in Michigan, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.